Labour's first Budget under Andy Burnham has been assessed by experts as failing a 'minimal test of credibility' and potentially leading to a £30 billion deficit in public finances. The National Institute of Economic Research (NIESR) warned that Chancellor John Healey postponed addressing the challenge of reducing borrowing.
NIESR's analysis indicated that the government's 'hesitancy' could worsen Britain's economic outlook, with future financial balance relying on 'good luck'. David Aikman, NIESR director, stated that a plan lacking belief increases the premium the government pays to borrow. He noted that despite 98 measures announced, the Budget did not tackle the significant issues of borrowing and the £3 trillion national debt.
While Mr Healey theoretically met targets to lower borrowing, with a £15 billion buffer, this 'headroom' had decreased from £24 billion in the spring. Achieving this reduced buffer was based on assumptions that Labour would implement 'austerity'-type spending cuts in some departments in the coming years. NIESR suggested that these plans might be abandoned in next year's spending review, potentially eliminating the headroom and missing targets by £30 billion.
The NIESR report also highlighted that soaring debt levels, while expected to peak in a couple of years, are still forecast to be higher in 2031/32 than they are currently. The report concluded that the 'minimal test of credibility' for the Chancellor, concerning stabilising the debt-to-GDP ratio, was not met based on Office for Budget Responsibility forecasts.