The question on everyone's lips ahead of today's Makerfield by-election is whether Andy Burnham has what it takes to make the leap from Greater Manchester Mayor to national leader. The Labour Party leadership hopeful's ability to transition from a prominent regional figure to a Prime Minister in waiting has come under intense scrutiny, with a scathing opinion piece published by City AM casting doubt on his capacity for this jump.
The article, penned by Alys Denby, Opinion and Features Editor at City AM, scrutinises Mr Burnham's past, recalling his tumultuous tenure as Health Secretary during the New Labour era. Critics point to his involvement in the Mid Staffs hospital scandal, earning him the nickname "bodybags Burnham", as evidence of a leadership style that may not translate well to the national stage.
Moreover, the commentary highlights what it describes as a series of 'U-turns' on significant policy issues. These include shifting positions on single-sex spaces, ruling out compensation for the WASPI women after previously expressing support, and comments on the bond markets labelled as economically illiterate. The author suggests these changes of mind indicate a politician "weak and desperate to be liked", unwilling to hold firm on potentially unpopular stances.
Should Mr Burnham secure the Makerfield seat and subsequently challenge Sir Keir Starmer for the Labour leadership, the article posits that he would advocate for policies such as increased public spending, renationalisation, and rejoining the European Union. While these positions might resonate with certain segments of the Labour membership, the piece argues they present a "dire prospectus" for a country in need of economic growth and stability.
The City AM opinion piece concludes by urging Makerfield voters to consider the broader implications of their choice, suggesting they are not merely electing a local MP but potentially influencing the next Prime Minister. It invokes the 'Peter Principle,' implying that while Mr Burnham may have excelled as Mayor of Greater Manchester, this might represent the highest office for which he is truly competent.
Source: City AM