Facebook
Britain's News Portal
Around The Clock
BREAKING
Loading latest headlines…

Doctor barred from treating patients gave evidence in two prosecutions

Professor Peter Hindmarsh, excluded from clinical practice during the Lucy Letby trial, later provided expert evidence in a separate neglect case against two parents.

  • Prof Peter Hindmarsh was excluded from clinical practice by UCLH in March 2023 due to safety concerns regarding his advice on insulin to child patients.
  • He provided expert evidence that helped convict Lucy Letby, and later produced a report for the prosecution of Damion and Tamara Thomas.
  • The Thomases, convicted of neglect and manslaughter respectively, are appealing their convictions.

A doctor who provided expert evidence in the Lucy Letby trial, Professor Peter Hindmarsh, was barred from treating patients during that trial. He was subsequently instructed as an expert witness in another prosecution.

The Guardian reported this week that UCLH, Professor Hindmarsh's employer, excluded him from clinical practice in March 2023. This decision was made during the main trial of Lucy Letby, and the jury was not informed. Reasons for the exclusion included concerns that his advice to child patients regarding insulin was not considered safe.

Professor Hindmarsh went on to produce an expert report in August 2023 for the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) in a case against Damion and Tamara Thomas. The Thomases were accused of neglecting their son, Joshua, 12, who died after a diabetes episode. Professor Hindmarsh concluded that Joshua's symptoms would have been clear and medical help should have been sought earlier.

In March this year, Tamara Thomas was convicted of gross negligence manslaughter and neglect, receiving a sentence of three years and nine months. Damion Thomas was found guilty of neglect and sentenced to two years and nine months. The Thomases maintain their innocence and have applied to the court of appeal for permission to appeal their convictions.

Why this matters: The exclusion of an expert witness from clinical practice due to safety concerns, and the lack of disclosure of this information in court, has raised questions about the reliability of evidence in significant legal cases.

Related Articles

Get the news that matters.

Join thousands of readers getting the best of British news straight to their inbox.