A New South Wales coroner's court heard competing narratives on Wednesday as part of an ongoing inquest into the deaths of four babies born in free births or home births in the northern rivers region between 2022 and 2024.
Baby DH was born in an inflatable pool at his parents' home near Byron Bay, with no medically trained person present. The baby lived for just over eight hours. The court heard that from his first minutes, Baby DH showed signs that something was seriously wrong, including a purple body, floppiness, and struggling to breathe.
The parents claim their doula, Amy Lou Smith, reassured them Baby DH was fine, then left to inflate a jumping castle while the baby's condition worsened. Smith, however, told the court that everything seemed acceptable and she suggested they seek more help if they wished. Smith denied her advice constituted clinical advice and stated she believed if parents had real concerns, they would call an ambulance.
Neonatologist Dr Paul Evans found Baby DH had a complex heart defect that could have been treated, and his death was not inevitable. Smith, who became a birth doula in 2020, has a degree in fine art and is not medically trained. She conceded she did not know what a low-risk birth would look like and now believes a clinically trained midwife should work alongside a doula for home births.