The UK government has lost a bid to keep its Apple surveillance order a secret, following a tribunal ruling against the Home Office. The Home Office had sought not to confirm or deny a notice issued to Apple that would have compelled the company to share encrypted data.
The Home Office argued that publicly confirming or denying the existence of a technical capability notice (TCN) would harm national security. However, the tribunal rejected this argument, stating that the Home Office's national security assessment was "flawed in the public law sense". The tribunal noted that the notice's existence is already widely known and easily accessible, therefore official confirmation would not pose a new national security risk.
While the TCN's existence is now public, its specific technical details remain confidential. Apple had initiated its second legal action against the government at the Investigatory Powers Tribunal after media reports indicated the Home Office had issued another notice seeking access to encrypted data. This occurred less than a year after an earlier order against Apple was withdrawn by Whitehall following a diplomatic dispute with Washington.
The government's notice was issued under the UK's Investigatory Powers Act (IPA), which permits the Home Secretary to issue TCNs and compel tech companies to provide access to encrypted data. Apple has refused to create a backdoor, stating that weakening encryption for UK users would compromise its global security. The company also removed its advanced data protection (ADP) feature from the UK due to a disagreement with the government.
The tribunal criticised "authorised leaks" to The Times and The Financial Times that confirmed the order, stating these undermined the government's argument that official confirmation would harm national security. Home Office witnesses claimed leak investigations found no government source, but the tribunal noted a lack of investigation reports, details of steps taken, or witness statements from Ministers denying authorisation of the briefings.