The Scottish government has ordered an independent review into hepatobiliary surgery at NHS Grampian. This decision comes after a whistleblower, Dr Mohammed Habib, leaked a document reportedly showing 19 avoidable deaths at the health board.
Dr Habib's leaked 2022 report indicated that 19 out of 31 deaths in liver and pancreatic surgery cases were avoidable. He also alleged that two individuals died after undergoing incorrect procedures and has called for a corporate homicide inquiry into the health board.
Health Secretary Angela Constance announced the review to investigate how concerns, including those raised by Dr Habib, were handled by NHS Grampian and the Scottish government. The review aims to identify governance weaknesses, missed opportunities, delays, and accountability gaps.
Ms Constance described Dr Habib's concerns as "deeply concerning and of the utmost seriousness." She is expected to provide a timetable and announce the review's leader in Holyrood on Tuesday. The Scottish government has stated that any issues, including potential criminality, will be referred to authorities without waiting for the final report.
Separately, First Minister John Swinney announced a review of government correspondence handling after claiming he only learned of three letters sent to him by Dr Habib on Thursday. Humza Yousaf, who was Health Secretary at the time of Dr Habib's report, has expressed support for "further dramatic action" at NHS Grampian and full transparency.
Patients with questions or needing advice and support regarding these concerns can contact the NHS Grampian helpline on 08085 202030. Additionally, an expert health team has been appointed to oversee improvements at NHS Grampian, and Healthcare Improvement Scotland has been asked to conduct an early review within three months.