Under Edinburgh Castle's twilight sky, James Taylor conjured up a spellbinding performance that had the 11,000-strong summer crowd entranced. At 78, the veteran singer-songwriter still boasts a voice that can melt hearts – his golden baritone a powerful instrument that can reduce even the most seasoned listener to a swoon.
The concert was a mixed bag in terms of presentation, with Taylor's civility and 'avuncular charm' a consistent highlight. But when the slick professionalism of the 11-piece backing band threatened to overpower the music, it was clear that less could indeed be more. Songs like 'Millworker', stripped back to its bare essentials, allowed Taylor's voice to take centre stage – its emotional depth sending shivers down the spines of those in attendance.
The visual elements, unfortunately, couldn't match the musical magic on show. The large-screen projections behind the stage were a mishmash of confusing graphics and unappealing visuals that failed to do justice to Taylor's timeless classics. 'Sweet Baby James', one of his most iconic songs, deserved far more than the garish backdrop it got – its beauty lost in a sea of neon lights.
Despite these missteps, the evening was peppered with poignant moments that left the crowd and critics alike in awe. Taylor's rendition of Carole King's 'You've Got a Friend' was delivered with raw emotion, while his performance of 'Carolina in My Mind' took on a haunting quality when sung as a tight choral group. And then there was 'Fire and Rain', a song that has been performed countless times but still manages to reduce Taylor to tears. A subtle lyrical tweak in the final line – directly addressing the friend whose tragic loss inspired the composition – sent shivers down his spine and had the audience hanging on every word.
In the end, it was clear that Taylor's enduring appeal lies not just in his music but in the raw emotion he brings to every performance. While the production fell short at times, the power of his artistry – particularly when allowed to shine in its most stripped-back moments – left a lasting impression on all who were lucky enough to be there.