M&S organic traditional oats have been judged as the best overall supermarket porridge, scoring five stars in a recent taste test. The Scottish oat flakes were noted for their fresh, sweet, nutty aroma and, when cooked, produced a velvety porridge with a tender bite and a gentle, umami nuttiness.
For those seeking value, Mornflake Mighty oats were named the 'best bargain', achieving a four-star rating. These wholegrain British oats from a family mill in Crewe were described as creating a dense porridge with a chewy, risotto-like texture and a mellow, rounded flavour.
The test also found that organic oats generally offered more flavour compared to conventionally grown varieties. Other highly-rated options included Tesco organic oats, Flahavan’s organic porridge oats, Co-op Irresistible Scottish jumbo rolled oats, and Glebe Farm PureOaty gluten-free organic porridge oats, all receiving four stars.
Lower-scoring options included Aldi Everyday Essentials porridge oats and Waitrose Scottish oats, both receiving two stars. Aldi's offering was described as 'bland, faintly sugary and cardboardy', while Waitrose's produced a thin but well-combined porridge.