A year after Ofsted introduced a report card system to replace single-word judgments for schools, the revised framework continues to face criticism. The change followed a coroner's verdict in 2023, which found that an inspection contributing to a school's downgrading played a part in the death of headteacher Ruth Perry.
Despite the reforms, critics remain frustrated. The National Association of Head Teachers attempted to challenge the updated framework in the high court. A survey indicated that two-thirds of responding teachers believe the new inspections are either as bad as or worse than the previous system.
In October, Education Secretary Lucy Powell announced that further reforms are anticipated. It is expected that the framework will be adjusted to better consider a school's context and to alleviate workload pressures.
Analysis suggests that schools in England with more deprived student populations are significantly less likely to meet expected standards compared to schools with low deprivation. This raises questions about whether inspections adequately account for the challenges faced by schools in poorer areas.