As a new season of 'The Celebrity Traitors' begins, psychologists suggest that a contestant's likability is a more significant advantage than their intelligence or tactical ability. According to chartered counselling psychologist Amanda Charles, all previous winners of the show, regardless of whether they were Traitors or Faithfuls, shared the common trait of being liked and trusted by their fellow players.
Dr. Carolyne Keenan, a registered psychologist, explains that humans quickly judge if someone feels safe and trustworthy. This social connection is crucial in the game, as chartered counselling psychologist Dr. Kirstie Fleetwood-Meade notes that for a Traitor, being liked can offer 'social protection', making others less inclined to suspect them.
Consultant counselling psychologist Dr. Ritz Birah highlights that likability can create a 'social shield', leading fellow contestants to interpret ambiguous behaviour generously. The article points to Alan Carr's performance as a Traitor in the BBC's first celebrity season as a prime example, where his self-deprecation and humour helped him avoid suspicion despite moments of pressure.